I always thought this is what the ending should have been like, so here it is. Different in many ways, but still not being able to be without each other. And if in some distant place in the future we see each other in our new lives, ill smile at you with joy and remember how we spent the summer beneath the trees, learning from each other and growing in love. The notebook is a 2004 romantic drama film directed by nick cassavetes and written by. In my opinion, the movie is a great addendum to a wellwritten novel. Message in a bottle, a walk to remember, the notebook, nights in rodanthe, dear john, the last song, the lucky one, safe haven, and most recently the longest ride. The emotional scale of the movie was increased dramatically that none of the events actually happened in the book. So the movie closing off with 2 birds flying close together in a flock signifies that noahs and allies love is a forever kinda thing. Instead of briony having a monologue about everything thats happened with her writing and cecilia and robbie, the film sets the ending up as an interview with briony, which, in my opinion, was more effective. According to twitter users, the netflix version fades to black after older allie and noah hold hands in bed. The movie ends with the two of them found dead on a bed holding hands with one another. The notebook deleted scene nobody else for me 2004 ryan gosling, rachel mcadams movie hd duration. Now, to be quite honest i am not a reader, but for some reason i had a gut feeling that this book would be worth my time, before watching the movie.
Movies is netflix secretly giving us a sequel to the notebook their alternate ending is more like the book which has a sequel. Netflix have denied changing the ending of the notebook after fans complained that the films final scene was completely different the film, which stars ryan gosling and rachel mcadams. Why does a movie like the notebook appeal to so many. We see them in the urgency of young romance, and then we see them as old people, she disappearing into the shadows of alzheimers, he steadfast in his love. But again, i was okay with it as i actually preferred it to the ending of the book, which was a little ambiguous for my taste. Speculation about the supposed tweak inspired this gallery of movies based on books that have similar tweaks. Netflix uk uploaded an alternative ending to the notebook. The notebook the notebook, written by nicolas sparks, can be named one of the best american romantic novels. Ryan gosling just cant fit the image of noah described in the book i havent read the book yet, but i am interested. I think that noah had been trying for a couple of times to let allie remember everything permanently. What seperates this from other chick flicks is that this is told throuh the eyes of a man who tells the relationship. Allie does remember noah in the end and he does spend the. I wasnt aware of the book with the same title and plot published in 1996. The indian bollywood film, zindagi tere naam, starring mithun chakraborty, is also based on it.
The movie showed a dramatic climax to the love story of the couple through a kiss under the rain. He jumps on the ferris wheel until she agrees to go out with him. I prefer the movie ending simply because the book ending ruined the characters. Netflix apparently changed the ending of the notebook.
Our goal is to save you time and money by sharing our thoughts and recommendations on which movies to race to theaters for, which to watch at home and those to actively avoid. The nicholas sparks tearjerker the notebook has some great old houses to look at. Netflix adds original version of the notebook after. There were many obstacles to a noahallie happy ending, most specifically wwii and her parents, especially her mother, who did not approve of the relationship and did whatever she could to end it. The plot of the movie primarily focuses on noah and allies lives in their youth.
The notebook is a 1996 romantic novel by american novelist nicholas sparks, the novel was later adapted into a popular film of the same name, in 2004. In a nursing home, resident duke reads a romance story for an old woman who has senile dementia with memory loss. But relapses and is taken away from dukeolder noah. As a stand alone movie the notebook is good movie but having read the book first the movie was a disappointment especially the ending. Their alternate ending is more like the book which has a sequel. The ending of the book was only to a point that allie was able to recognize noah despite of her diagnosis to alzheimeris.
I finished the book yesterday and felt strongly compelled to watch the movie again the same day. Analysis of the book the notebook essay 48 words 6 pages. So, imagine the internets collective surprise to find out that in the version of the notebook currently playing on u. The real reason the notebook has a different ending on.
The original ends with allie gena rowlandsrachel mcadams becoming lucid after noah james garnerryan gosling reads her the story of their lives. The official website of nicholas sparks, american novelist, screenwriter and producer. The time travelers wife was the ending of the book or. I wrote a new post about noahs plantation house from this movie with more photos and information that you can see here. I had read notebook a number of times before watching the movie. Comparison between the notebook movie and book essay. In the movie noah and allie hang out together at the carnival until it is over. What makes alternate ending different from other film sites and podcasts. The houses and filming locations from the movie the notebook. The most dramatic part of the movie was the ending where they. Others have suggested that this ending is more in line with the book, opening up room to make a movie of the sequel novel, the wedding, which is. The real reason the notebook has a different ending on netflix.
For the best answers, search on this site whos afraid of virginia woolf. The notebook is about to be added to netflix in the us, but its already available in the uk and fans are not happy with the big change that they made at the end. Differences between the notebook book vs movie page 1. Allies, noahs, and the old plantation house that served as the nursing home lets take a closer look at all three. The movie always changes the book but the one major change the ending which had the audience letting out a collective gasp and reaching for the nearest tissue was, in my opinion, really good even if it was pure hollywood melodrama. On november 11, 2012, abc family premiered an extended version with deleted. Netflix accused of changing the notebook final scene. The movie is wonderful and in the end, i dont know anyone who wouldnt shed a tear. At the end of the notebook, we see allie and noah dead together holding each others hands. In the months leading up to gone girls release, the press has obsessed over whether or not writer gillian flynn changed the ending of her book when adapting it for the big screen. The film became a sleeper hit and has gained a cult following. The notebook cuts between the same couple at two seasons in their lives.
The notebook ending controversially changed by netflix uk. The notebook may have premiered in 2005, but there are still so many things you dont know about the iconic movie. But the director of the notebook film was very respectful and there are only minor changes and maybe a different interpretation of the ending. Analysis of the notebook essay 1564 words bartleby. Due to their difference in social class, allies parents were never fond of noah, and. The movie also ends slightly differently than the book. Is netflix secretly giving us a sequel to the notebook.
It is his custom every day to read to her from a notebook that tells the story of how they met and fell in love and faced obstacles to their happiness. Literary agent theresa park discovered sparks by picking the book out of her. Im not bitter any more, because i know that what we had was real. The notebooks ending is different on netflix, and people are. It was a great book, and with a cast of compelling characters, it could have been a phenomenal movie but instead, the 2009 film, directed by. In both book and film, he says that he doesnt want her to wait for him. Were the two endings perhaps the result of differing censorship requirements in different markets, a special directors cut edition featuring previously unused footage, or simply. This is my ideal ending for the movie the notebook. Then later that night, duke goes to allies room and sleep beside her. Imagine sitting back, queuing up the notebook on netflix, and being served up a noticeably different ending.
That happy noah allie ending is not a guarantee due to these. If you dont get emotional during the movie or while reading the book, youll most certainly cry at the end of the story. But the expected miracle did not happen a single time, and every time she lost everything. The uk netflix platform has reportedly changed the notebook ending, riling up fans who were anticipating the sad ending the film is famous for. Netflix changed the ending of the notebook and people are. In the late 1930s, wealthy seventeen yearold allie hamilton is spending summer vacation in seabrook. The notebook is a very good movie, a fun movie, but at times a boring movie. It ends differently than the movie does and, in my opinion, has a better ending than the movie. Netflix uk streams the notebook with edited ending, author nicholas sparks reacts. Then the movie goes back to the present time and older allie remembers that that was their love story. The book portrays every trait in a guy or girl would desire to have in a significant. Thats what happened to fans streaming the film on netflix across the pond.
Local worker noah calhoun meets allie at a carnival and they soon fall in. Netflix uk changes the ending to the notebook indiewire. The most dramatic part of the movie was the ending where they both end up in. The last few minutes of the notebook are a tearjerker and a beautiful ending to noah and allies love story. Fans of the romantic tearjerker he notebook were left outraged upon learning the netflix version playing in the united kingdom omitted the films sad ending for a more happier outcome. Alternate ending was formed when three friends realized they all shared a passion for movies. The notebook is a movie based on a bestselling novel that was written by author nicholas sparks. Here are 15 the notebook quotes that will make you fall in love with love. Allies part in the book was expanded for the movie. Are there two different versions of the films ending. In both book and film, henry claims to love clare, and part of this love is wanting what is best for her. The notebooks ending has been changed and people are fuming. The real reason the notebook has a different ending on netflix u. Whats the difference between the notebook the book and the notebook the movie.
He has seventeen published novels as of september 20 plus one nonfiction. Netflix uk accidentally streamed the notebook with an alternate ending. By killing off noah it did not leave any room for the book after the notebook to be produced. Instead of watching the older noah and allie clutch hands as they passed away sorry if we just spoiled it for you, fans of. It previously denied changing the notebooks ending and confirmed that it was supplied with an alternate cut of the movie carrying a different ending. I couldnt sleep last night because i know that its over between us.
996 1230 1169 381 936 271 89 934 1309 482 1222 1248 1557 1377 1552 305 221 249 322 313 808 1227 960 878 1259 1111 581 1375 308 1334 1217